Turnout Down For Firefighters Gathering
Emergency personnel march to honor those who gave lives
By Kenton Robinson
Published on 10/7/2007 TheDay.com
Norwich— Ninety-nine.

Each year, for the past 15, hundreds of firefighters have marched down Broadway to honor their fallen colleagues.

Saturday the marchers numbered 99.

The reason given, more whispered than spoken aloud in the knots of blue serge gathered on the yellowed grass of the Chelsea Parade, was a boycott.

Firefighters snubbed the Norwich diocese's annual parade and Mass to honor them, they said, because organizers of this year's event banned firetrucks from the procession.

“They like bringing their truck, showing it off, you know?” said Buddy Hernandez, past captain of the Portland Fire Department. “They spend a lot of time cleaning it up and stuff, and it's what we do, you know?”

“Volunteers are very proud of their equipment and what they do,” said Alfred Brooks, past chief of the Mystic Fire Department. “And they don't do it for money.” The ban on trucks, he said, “kind of hurt them.”

“If they don't want to be here, shame on them,” seethed Chief Kenneth Scandariato of the Norwich Fire Department.

Two Connecticut firefighters lost their lives this year, he said — Capt. Joseph Pagano Jr. of Middletown and Capt. John Keane of Waterbury — and he had asked their chiefs how they wanted their men to be honored.

They said “that the best way firefighters can honor the dead is to walk for them, not ride,” Scandariato said, and so he made those feelings known to those who headed up the committee planning the Mass.

“This isn't about me, and it shouldn't be about anybody that's standing here today. I'm just coming to make sure that those they've left behind know that I still care about the sacrifice they made. I don't even need to be in the dress blues to do that,” Scandariato said.

“So if they want to boycott, what were they really here for to begin with? To ride on the apparatus? Or to honor the dead?”

The Mass is to honor both firefighters and emergency medical service personnel, and it usually draws people from across the state. On Saturday there were people from Mystic, Bozrah, Stafford Springs, Danbury, Griswold, Cromwell and Tolland.

But in a city which, between its fire department and volunteer companies, has some 350 firefighters of its own, the slender turnout startled many.

“It would be nice” to have the trucks, said Sandy Nordgren, rescue lieutenant for the Bozrah Fire Department, “but that's not why we're here.”

“There's usually a much bigger turnout,” said Joe Comarrella, deputy chief of the West Stafford Fire Department, who has attended the Mass for the past 10 years and now stared across the virtually vacant field of the parade.

Describing the boycott as a “rumor,” Matthew Traber, chairman of the Mass committee, said, “There is a staggering decrease in people that have come, and for the 15th anniversary this year, we tried to do something new, and bring a little bit more homage to it.”

“No one has called me. No one has walked up to me. No one has sent me a letter or e-mail. I've got nothing,” said Mark Sicuso, the committee's co-chairman.

“You know,” said Traber, “It's all about sacrifice, I believe, and honoring those that have ...”

“... made the ultimate sacrifice,” Sicuso interrupted. “The least we can do is walk a quarter mile.”

Traber said he had envisioned something much more grand.

“You know, I enjoy watching a military procession. They're straight and narrow, and they're very professional,” he said. “There's something about a firefighters' procession. It's just a bunch of grouped firemen walking unevenly, bouncing down the road, and it's just got this unique bit to it, you know.”

And so, cradling axes and preceded by bagpipes, the 99 firefighters marched from the Chelsea Parade to the Cathedral of St. Patrick, where they prayed and remembered their dead.

“It's not about the firetrucks,” said Sicuso. “It's about the people. People put out fires, not firetrucks.”

 

R E A D E R'S C O M M E N T S

Posted- 10/9/2007 12:10:47 AM To Steve from Preston - - - truth hurts doesn't it. These are not cheap comments...just the truth of the real world!
New London, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/8/2007 4:08:56 PM Sorry if the weekend warrior comment offended anyone Steve, but the quote "They like bringing their truck, showing it off, you know?" said Buddy Hernandez, past captain of the Portland Fire Department. "They spend a lot of time cleaning it up and stuff, and it's what we do, you know" is not how I want to be portrayed as a firefighter. I would like the fire service to be portrayed as a professional group (career or volunteer), that is committed to saving lives, property, and maybe even committed to properly memorializing our fallen. This is what we should be doing, "you know". It is no longer about having a sparkling clean fire truck "you know". The quote "There's something about a firefighters' procession. It's just a bunch of grouped firemen walking unevenly, bouncing down the road, and it's just got this unique bit to it, you know" is dreadful. First of all we should all be known as "firefighters", and secondly I would like to think that we are a little more organized than what was stated by this uninformed individual. I was not out to hurt any feelings, however, I wish the fire service would step-up and do a little better in regards to public service, public relations and public perception. I too have attended this mass many times but have never felt the need to do so by bringing a shiny fire engine to properly remember those who have served and continue to serve their communities. Maybe we as the fire service should be better at following the chain of command and honoring the wishes of those who have given their precious time putting together such a worthy event. Stay safe all. Jeffrey
East Lyme
 

 

Posted- 10/8/2007 11:59:00 AM As usual, some people have taken a stance or opinion to one extreme or the other. Some people have also used personal agendas to post on this subject. As a volunteer Firefighter who has MARCHED in this parade and Mass for the past several years, I too was disappointed to learn of the ban on trucks this year. I was unable to attend either way, but was disappointed none-the-less. Some departments also use this memorial "parade" and Mass as a time to have their trucks blessed, and to show off the way they have memorialized the past fallen firefighters with their antiques and current equipment. That perspective was taken away from some people, and yes, some avoided the event because of it. I would like to think that most had other engagements, but the numbers do lead one to believe otherwise. See you at the Mass next year, on foot or wheel. As far as the posts above about the Ma. Firefighters and the cost of gas and the weekend warriors comment, you people are callous, shallow, and uninformed. The first amendment gives you the right to free speech, but most people would pay for you to keep your cheap comments to yourself. Steve
Preston, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 10:37:37 PM Again... SHAME on The Day.I'm very disappointed in this reporter. His questions were squarely focused on this perceived controversy, and not at all objective as we are always led to believe the press is. Since Kenton Robinson chose not to include my responses to his questions in his story because they didn't fit his angle, I'll say them again here. The fact is that there have been less people attending this mass over the years... and I've been to every one. I believe that the actual number of malcontents that chose not to attend because of the Mass Committees decision to conduct the procession differently, are really very few. And their individual decision should NOT be assumed to be representative of the fire service in general. It is more likely an issue of simple math. Each year there have been less participants. Perhaps it is connected to the fact that most volunteer fire departments have fewer members each year as well (with some rare exceptions.) Last year there were fewer participants than the year before, the same the year before that, and so on. That cycle will likely continue... unless this years coverage motivates some people. Also, there are some Connecticut firefighters that went to the National Fallen Firefighters Memorial in Emmitsburg, MD yesterday (President Bush participated again this year as he did in 2001.) There are lots of legitimate reasons for people not being able to attend. Not the least of which is the decline in volunteerism. It also should be noted that although the overall number of marchers was less this year, nearly all southeastern CT fire departments were represented at the mass. Additionally, there were departments that traveled over an hour to participate in this mass. I commend the Firefighters/EMS Mass Committee for their work and for making a difficult but correct decision. Being in a leadership position is never easy and those Chiefs' that disagree with their decision should be well aware of that themselves. This is one rare occassion where the Bulletin has done a better job reporting than The Day. Read that story here:http://www.norwichbulletin.com/homepage/x1910578190 fred K. Potter
Bozrah, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 6:03:46 PM Fire trucks are not known for great gas mileage. Who would pay for the gas for fire trucks driven in from all over the state to be driven in the parade. There is also wear & tear on the vehicles. Do these guys think that the trucks belong to them just because they are firemen? The only difference between men & boys is the cost of their toys.
New London, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 3:07:57 PM This is just another example of people who have chosen the business of public safety as a hobby. These particular people are nothing more than weekend warriors. Unfortunately the fire service has become more about individuals and personal agendas and less about the real mission, which is to save lives and property. The "itsallaboutme.com theory" doesn't work when human lives are at stake. If these firefighters wouldn't come out for a service to remember their own fallen brothers, are they really going to show up for the routine alarm. I am concerned about the route the fire service is going and it has become obvious that many changes are needed. Lets remember why the fire department was created and get back on track, no matter what hard choices it may take. This is just one of many black eyes for the fire service recently and there will be more to come if we cannot come up with a better solution on how to handle our business. If we don't come up with a plan that works, someone else will figure it out for us. Jeffrey
East Lyme
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 2:31:22 PM My name is Matthew Traber and I am the chairman of the Firefighters / EMS Mass Committee. Shame on Kenton Robinson, the author of this article. Kenton Robinson walked around the ninety-nine firefighters dressed in blue in Norwich yesterday with a thought of knowledge that some people were upset about the change in the Mass Procession. Did he ask anyone what being there meant to them? I’ll bet not. He didn’t ask me that. Did he give as much as one sentence listing the names of Capt. Joseph Pagano Jr. of Middletown or Capt. John Keane or Waterbury who both lost their lives this year? No, Chief Scandariato of Norwich mentioned them. Did he mention that the Taftville Fire Dept. and the Mashantucket Pequot Fire Dept. tower ladders held the giant flag owned by the New London County Fire Chief Association as a memorial arch? No he didn't. Did he mention Father Joel Warden who traveled from Brooklyn, NY and gave a homily that dealt with faith and how faith drives we emergency services workers to do our best every time so that our communities are safe? No he didn’t. His article was completely and totally negative. Someone planted a bug in Mr. Robinson’s ear and he traveled to Norwich yesterday to discredit and disrespect an honorable occasion. Ninety-nine firefighters and emergency services personnel marched down Broadway yesterday in the eighty-five degree heat silently and solemnly showing respect and reverence to those that have given the ultimate sacrifice while in the performance of their duty. Shame on you Mr. Robinson for not detailing the reason we were all there. I think we deserve an apology.I tip my hat to all the emergency professionals that attended the Mass. All ninety-nine of you waited in the afternoon heat waiting for your chance to honor those that have gone before up doing the job we love. Thank you for being a part of it with us. Matthew A. Traber
Mansfield, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 1:53:14 PM It would be nice if all of the facts were stated. It is not a Mass to commemorate the loss of life but a Mass to honor those who are willing to make the sacrifice and those that have made the supreme sacrifice. This Mass is a chance for me as a wife and a step-mother of firefighters to go and say thank you for another day with my family and still be there for other families that are not able to say the same thing. It is not about fire trucks or even the fire chief's it is about the firefighters and emergency personnel that run into a building that everyone is running out of.And by the way, in many ways, it is about the fire trucks and ambulances,. Without them the fires would not be put out. The injured would not make it to the hospital. Bonnie Cuprak
Norwich, CT
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 12:43:49 PM Brothers, remember this was a MEMORIAL not a parade! You didn't hurt the diocese's by not showing up, you disrespected and failed to honor your fallen comrades. Keep this in mind for next year!!! Brother Firefighter
Mystic
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 12:10:42 PM This article is misleading. My department attends every year however we were unable to attend this year due to a heavy volume of events in our town that required staffing. In fact, I had no idea trucks weren't allowed, this would NEVER be an influence on our departments participation in such an event to honor our fallen brothers.
New London County
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 11:19:54 AM "I'm not going to the beach if I can't take my beach ball" - - that is something you would expect a spoiled kid to tell a parent. Seems like the fire fighters in are "spoiled kids". The church holds a Mass to honor fallen fire fighters and because these "adults" can't bring their "toys" with them, they won't attend. That says a lot of what they think of their fallen comrades. Having their fire trucks to ride on & show off is more important than honoring fallen comrades. This week it was reported that 2 fire fighters that died on Boston, one was drunk, more than 3 times the legal limit, the other had cocaine in his system. I wonder how many of these fallen fire fighters died because of their own stupidity. A fire fighter who is drunk and dies in a fire in no better than a drunk driver who dies in a traffic accident. Do we honor drunk driver who have died? This display was shameful. The church should not hold another Mass for fallen fire fighters, they do not appreciate it.
New London
 

 

Posted- 10/7/2007 11:12:23 AM I agree in whole with the comments, it is about the loss of the firefighter, not the fire apparatus. Those unwilling to attend the event because they could not bring their truck need to do some serious soul searching. Keith J. Robbins
Bozrah, CT